Some Bands Catch No Plagues: Saetia Live in Berlin
In July 2025, NYC screamo legends Saetia started their first ever European tour with a show at Berlin's SO36.
Whenever I write about a gig I’ve attended, I always end up feeling like a fool. Especially when it’s a highly anticipated reunion show. Within hours, often minutes, there’s already a flood of photos, setlists, shaky vertical videos, etc. This one’s no exception.
I flew out to Berlin, arguably the most gig-bloated city in Europe, to catch NYC’s legends Saetia live. Berlin is a city where you can eat all the vegan food you want and see your dream line-up every weekend, if you’ve got the stamina. Case in point: the night before Saetia, the city hosted Berlin Breakout festival, which brought in bands like As Friends Rust. Hardcore tourists were out in full force.
For those who don’t know the backstory, Saetia was a short-lived band from New York City, active from February 1997 to October 1999. Despite their super brief existence, they were in the right place at the right time to become an underground cult. Along with groups like Orchid, Jeromes Dream, Pageninetynine, and Reversal of Man, most of whom have also recently done reunion laps, Saetia became synonymous with the so-called “real screamo” wave. When they reunited in 2022, their 1999 lineup of Billy Werner on vocals, Adam Marino on guitar, and Colin Bartoldus on bass returned. Steve Roche, formerly a guitarist and bassist, was now sitting behind the drum kit. They also added guitarist Tom Schlatter, a veteran of more incredible bands than I can reasonably list here.
I’ve always had a complicated relationship with reunions. There’s a part of me that believes some bands should stay in the past and move on to create new projects that reflect who they are now, not who they were twenty or thirty years ago. I once talked to Ian MacKaye about this, and he used a great analogy: when you’re young, your handwriting is one way, but as you get older and keep writing, it naturally changes. So why go back to writing in the exact same style when it no longer represents your current self? That said, I love Saetia, but I’m an even bigger fan of post-Saetia bands like Off Minor and Hot Cross. They never achieved the same level of posthumous popularity, though.
So, why care about Saetia in 2025? Saetia’s reunion is one of those rare cases where it actually feels right. When they came back in 2022, there was a genuine surge of interest in the style they helped shape back in the late ’90s. They didn’t waste that momentum. They played five sold-out shows and raised $31,000 for local benefits supporting trans rights and reproductive freedom. That alone would’ve been enough to justify the comeback, but it also showed they still had purpose and a message beyond mere nostalgia.
Saetia played some exclusive shows in the UK in 2023, including a legendary London gig that friends of mine caught, but it wasn’t until 2025 that the band entered a new chapter with the release of Tendrils, their first new material in over two decades. And with that came the announcement of a short European tour. Their Berlin date on July 6th, 2025 was not just a start of the tour, it was their first-ever appearance on mainland European soil.
Originally booked at Neue Zukunft, the show had to be moved to SO36 in Kreuzberg due to overwhelming demand. By the time I arrived at 8 pm, the venue was already packed. I ran into guitarist Tom Schlatter, chatted for a minute, and picked up a copy of Tendrils at the merch table. The opening band, LÖRI, came on shortly after. They’re a four-piece from Berlin playing a style of post-rock-tinged screamo with song titles written in Latin numerals. Their set had some decent ambient passages and the occasional blast beat eruption, but overall felt a little sterile and too predictable to leave much of a mark on me.
Saetia’s setup was quick and minimal. I stayed in the back for the first two songs, still unsure whether this would be as good as expected. For years, I’ve become quite bored with most of the current wave of metalcore and mosh hardcore bands. I haven’t felt connected to screamo for a while either. But it didn’t take long for Saetia to win me over. They were flawless. From the first chords, they played with the kind of conviction that made it impossible to look away. I rushed my way to the front and found myself caught in those passionate, beautiful moments when everything lines up. Crashing into strangers, diving off the stage, sharing the mic with Billy Werner, screaming along to lyrics that still sound like poetry carved from heartbreak and rage. The finer art of heartwork.
They played everything you could hope for: “The Sweetness and the Light,” “An Open Letter,” “Closed Hands,” “Some Natures Catch No Plagues,” “Venus and Bacchus,” “One Dying Wish,” and more. The entire crowd knew every word. They even mixed in a couple of new tracks from Tendrils, which surprisingly didn’t feel out of place next to the old classics.
The sound at SO36 was phenomenal, even if the venue itself felt a bit too fancy for this kind of music. Still, everything hit with purpose, every note was clear, and the band was beyond exceptional. For us, it was an emotional outlet; an hour of screaming along to timeless hardcore songs. For the band, it was a chance to reconnect with old friends on the other side of the Atlantic. If you’re lucky enough to catch Saetia on this tour, I have no doubt you’ll walk away floored. My only criticism is that, while playing in Germany and coming from the US under the second Trump administration, the band didn’t acknowledge the climate of censorship, repression, militarism, and complicity with some of the worst atrocities and genocides witnessed in recent times. For a band that is supposed to be engaged with progressive politics (nodding back to their original reunion shows in 2022), it felt a bit odd and a missed opportunity to use your platform as a popular band.
But still, what a set. What a band. Even after all these years, Saetia remains untouchable. Some bands burn out, others fade away. Some bands catch no plagues.